QCDs vs. Donor-Advised Funds: Which Is the Smarter Way to Give in 2026?

Two of the most effective tools for charitable giving today work in very different ways. A qualified charitable distribution (QCD) sends money straight from your IRA to a charity. A donor-advised fund (DAF) lets you take a deduction now and choose where the money goes later. The 2026 tax changes widened the gap between them, and choosing the right one can be worth thousands of dollars a year.

First, the quick facts:

Qualified charitable distributions

  • Who can use them: IRA owners 70½ or older. 401(k)s don’t qualify, so those dollars must be rolled into an IRA first.
  • How much: up to $111,000 per person in 2026. A one-time QCD of up to $55,000 can also fund a charitable gift annuity or charitable remainder trust.
  • The tax benefit: the gift never shows up in your income, and it counts toward your required minimum distribution.
  • Where it can go: directly to a public 501(c)(3) charity. Donor-advised funds, private foundations, supporting organizations and political groups can’t receive QCDs.

Donor-advised funds

  • Who can use them: anyone, at any age.
  • What you can give: cash, or investments you’ve held for more than a year, such as appreciated stock. We usually recommend giving appreciated stock rather than cash (more on why below).
  • The tax benefit: you get your deduction in the year you fund the DAF (if you itemize). If you give appreciated stock, you never pay capital gains tax on its growth, because you’re gifting the shares rather than selling them and giving the cash. Inside the DAF, the money can keep growing until you recommend a grant to the charity of your choice. That grant has no tax impact for you, good or bad, since you already received your deduction when you funded the account.
  • The limits: deductions are capped at 60% of your income for cash and 30% for appreciated stock, with any excess carried forward for up to five years. Gifts are irrevocable, and DAF grants can’t be used to fulfill a personal pledge or pay for event tickets or anything else that benefits you.
  • The cost: Fidelity Charitable Gift Fund, where many of our clients maintain donor-advised funds, has no minimum to open an account, a $50 minimum grant and an annual administrative fee of 0.60% or $100, whichever is greater, plus any investment fees (we waive our advisory fee on gift fund accounts, but you might have fees for owning a mutual fund or other investment in the account). It also requires you to recommend at least one grant every two years.

What changed in 2026:

  • A new floor for itemizers. Only gifts above 0.5% of your adjusted gross income are deductible if you itemize. With $300,000 of income, the first $1,500 you give earns no deduction. (This applies to charitable gifts in general, not just gifts to a donor-advised fund.)
  • A new cap for top earners. For those in the 37% bracket, the deduction is now worth at most 35 cents per dollar.
  • A new deduction for everyone else. If you take the standard deduction, you can now deduct up to $1,000 ($2,000 for married couples) of cash gifts to public charities. Gifts to donor-advised funds don’t count.
  • QCDs weren’t touched. Because a QCD is excluded from income rather than deducted, neither the floor nor the cap applies.

Our take in brief:

  • If you’re 70½ or older and give from an IRA, start with a QCD. Most retirees now take the standard deduction, which means a check from the bank to a charity saves nothing in taxes. A QCD still does, at every income level.
  • A QCD beats a deduction, dollar for dollar. Every dollar you give through a QCD comes straight off your income, whether or not you itemize, and it also lowers the income that sets your Medicare premiums and Social Security taxes. A dollar given to a DAF only cuts your taxes if you itemize, only the portion above the new 0.5% floor counts, and for top earners each dollar is worth at most 35 cents.
  • A DAF shines in a big year. If you’re under 70½, have stock with large gains or have an unusually high-income year from a business sale, a bonus or a large Roth conversion, a DAF lets you capture the deduction when it’s worth the most.
  • Many of our clients use both. QCDs handle annual giving from the IRA, and a DAF holds appreciated stock to be granted out over time.

Three examples:

  • Margaret, 75, gives $10,000 a year and takes the standard deduction. Writing checks gets her no tax benefit. Sending the same $10,000 as a QCD lowers her taxable RMD from about $20,325 to $10,325, saving about $2,200 in federal tax at a 22% rate.
  • David and Susan, 62, sold their business this year and have $900,000 of income. Instead of writing checks, they give $100,000 of stock they bought for $20,000 to a DAF. They never pay capital gains tax on the $80,000 of growth, which saves about $19,000, and they get a deduction worth roughly $33,000 after the new floor and cap. They can recommend grants from the DAF for years to come.
  • Jim and Carol, 66, give $15,000 a year. Their itemized deductions fall short of the standard deduction, so their giving earns no tax benefit. By putting three years of giving ($45,000) into a DAF in one year, they itemize that year and take the standard deduction in the other two, while their charities still receive grants every year.

A few practical notes:

  • QCDs take a little paperwork. Brittany can set you up with an IRA checkbook so you can write QCD checks yourself, or she can send you a DocuSign to issue the check on your behalf.
  • If using a portion of your RMD, process the QCD first. Money already withdrawn to you can’t be turned into a QCD later, so we schedule QCDs before the rest of your RMD.
  • Give stock, not cash, to a DAF. Contributing investments with large gains avoids the capital gains tax entirely. Say you own stock you bought for $20,000 that’s now worth $100,000. Sell it and give the cash, and you owe tax on the $80,000 gain first. Give the shares instead, and the charity receives the full $100,000, you never pay the capital gains tax and, if you itemize, you deduct the full market value. Stock transfers take longer than cash, so start well before year-end.
  • A QCD can’t go into a DAF. If you’re 70½ or older and want both benefits, use QCDs for IRA dollars and give appreciated stock from a taxable account to the DAF.

Thinking about your giving for this year? Give us a call. We’re here and happy to help you decide which approach fits, how much to give and how it works alongside your RMDs and any Roth conversion.

This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. Nothing on it is investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice, and nothing on it recommends or offers to buy or sell any security. Tax and planning topics are general and may not apply to your situation. Tax laws also change often. Please consult a qualified tax or legal professional before acting on any information here. The information is believed to be reliable as of the date of publication. Baker Ellis Asset Management LLC does not guarantee its accuracy, and it may not be updated. Reading this blog does not create an advisory relationship.

← Back to all posts